Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Rise In The FutureRise In The Future

Editor's Pick

Should the Federal Government Subsidize Student Loans?

Jeffrey Miron

Media Name: 201305_studentloan.jpg

Recent debates over student loan cancellation ignore a fundamental question: should the federal government be subsidizing such loans in the first place?

The standard argument for this intervention is that, otherwise, some for whom higher ed is productive will be unable to finance such “investments” due to imperfections in private credit markets. That claim is plausible, but subsidizing such loans has negative effects as well.

Subsidizing loans can encourage excess, or the wrong kinds, of higher ed acquisition by those for whom it is not productive. This possibility is consistent with claims from some indebted students that they cannot find jobs that make use of their degrees. This is plausible, in part, because nothing ensures that loans are for training or degrees that enhance productivity.

The impact of credit market imperfections is also easily overstated. Many colleges and universities, as well as private foundations and for‐​profit companies, offer scholarships, fellowships, grants, and apprenticeships to those with limited funds.

Even if the market undersupplies education loans, moreover, the federal government should play no role, instead leaving any intervention to states. Federal subsidy implies federal definition and control of higher education, which opens the door to thought control and political manipulation (e.g., via debt cancellation).

Rather than forgiving federal student debt, therefore, the right policy is to phase out such programs going forward.

This article appeared on Substack on February 28, 2024.

You May Also Like

Editor's Pick

In this edition of StockCharts TV‘s The Final Bar, Dave and guest Julius de Kempenaer of RRG Research talk sector rotation, growth vs. value, offense vs....

Tech News

Screenshot: Wes Davis / The Verge There’s a little-known hack in rural America: you can get the best fried food at the gas station...

Tech News

Photo by Jakub Porzycki/NurPhoto via Getty Images Intel’s chip-making division accumulated $7 billion in operating losses in 2023, Reuters reported on Tuesday. That’s a...

Tech News

Photo by Amelia Holowaty Krales / The Verge Linux, the most widely used open source operating system in the world, narrowly escaped a massive...